Three weaknesses
⇄ Any orderFive parrots talk.
- Fragmented thinking and actiontransport spread over five ministries/departments in India, one department in the USA and UK
- Policy-making tangled with implementationSecretaries spend most of their time on routine administration
- Too little outside input and debate
Reforms — a career path that rewards expertise, and a Policy Advisory Group in each ministry (Secretary-level civil servants + stakeholders/industry + subject-expert academics) · law is made by the legislature, policy by the executive — a court strikes a policy down only if it breaks the Constitution or a law, not for being “unwise” (India–US nuclear deal, 2008).