← Maths

x + 1/x: Cycles, Limits and Several Variables

SSC CGL · CHSL · CPO — method by method

4 Part30 worked examples101 practice questions

The previous chapter (“x + 1/x Type Expressions”) taught climbing the ladder: to , … but climbing to is hopeless. For a few special values () the ladder values start repeating, and then any huge power is just a counting question inside the cycle. This chapter covers that cycle, then limit cases such as and minimum values, and finally and three-variable questions.

Before thisMake the ladder of that chapter (square, cube, multiply) solid first; here we take it as known.
1

Cycles

Special values · huge powers ·

The repeating of powers at special values of x + 1/x.

Three methods: spotting the cycle, bringing a huge power into the cycle, and finding the value of a polynomial from an equation like .

Special values and the cycle of powers

The cycle in which powers go round for .

The idea

Take . Multiply by : , i.e. . Now multiply by : . So , and then : after steps the powers are back where they started. That is the story of every special value. The direct rule: if some rung has then , i.e. and ; if then ; and if then .

∑ Formula
Reading the cycle off the ladder
the -th rung of the ladder
the power
◭ Diagram
x0xx2x3x4x5xⁿ + 1/xⁿn=0: 2n=1: 1n=2: −1n=3: −2n=4: −1n=5: 1back to start after 6 steps
: the powers of go round a circle in steps and are back after steps; is twice the horizontal position of that point. (The picture only explains the cycle.)
◭ Diagram
x0xx2x3x4x5x6x7x8x9x10x11xⁿ + 1/xⁿn=0: 2n=1: √3n=2: 1n=3: 0n=4: −1n=5: −√3n=6: −2n=7: −√3n=8: −1n=9: 0n=10: 1n=11: √3back to start after 12 steps
: the step is , so a cycle of steps; and .
EquationKey relationCycle (one cycle)

Here: the first column is the given value, the second the equation it makes, the third the power at which first appears, the fourth the length of the cycle (after how many powers everything repeats) and the last column the values of one cycle. always.

and are special too, but they come in later methods ( and ). The four commonest special values in exams are (cycle ), (cycle ), (cycle ) and or (cycle or ).

Spot itSpot it: the value of lies between and (like ) and the power is large. Count the ladder values first; the cycle shows at the first .

Steps

  1. Compute the ladder values in order ().
  2. At the first with write (if a zero appears, ).
  3. Take powers of that relation and carry on.
Example 1 · Basic
If , find and .
Solution, step by step
  1. 1The ladder: , , .
  2. 2 means , i.e. , so .
  3. 3Squaring gives .
Answer -1 ; 1
Alternative: multiplying by also gave .
Example 2 · Standard
If , find the cycle and then .
Solution, step by step
  1. 1, , .
  2. 2 means , i.e. and .
  3. 3So ; the cycle is powers long.
Answer 1
Note: the first appears at , which is exactly .
Example 3 · Standard
If , find and .
Solution, step by step
  1. 1, so .
  2. 2 means .
  3. 3, so .
Answer -1 ; 2
No real has , but the algebra formulas still work.
Example 4 · Advanced
If , find , and .
Solution, step by step
  1. 1, . A zero appeared, so , i.e. .
  2. 2.
  3. 3, and , so .
Answer -1 ; 1 ; -2
: you can reach any power by adding powers of the cycle.
Example 5 · Advanced
If , find .
Solution, step by step
  1. 1; .
  2. 2, .
  3. 3. This is , so : the cycle is long.
Answer 1
This five-cycle is rare; the ladder method still identifies it every time.

Practice

BasicTry it yourself first
If , then equals:
BasicTry it yourself first
If , then equals:
StandardTry it yourself first
If , then equals:
StandardTry it yourself first
If , then equals:
StandardTry it yourself first
If , then equals:
StandardTry it yourself first
If , then equals:
AdvancedTry it yourself first
If , then equals:
AdvancedTry it yourself first
If , then equals:
AdvancedTry it yourself first
If , then equals:

Huge powers: bring them into the cycle

Questions like without climbing the ladder.

The idea

When (cycle length ), everything repeats after every powers. So write ( is the remainder of ); then . A huge power is done with the small power : . It is the same “clock arithmetic” in which o’clock means o’clock. The cycle length comes from the table of the previous method.

∑ Formula
Bringing the power into the cycle
the given (large) power
the length of the cycle
the remainder of
the -th rung of the ladder
cycle

Here: the given value is on the left and its cycle on the right. Divide by , take the remainder, then read that in the table of the previous method.

The second form: a bare (without ) is reduced by the cycle too. If then and ; so . If then and a whole cycle of consecutive powers adds to .

Squaring roadA second road when is a power of two (, ): square again and again, . The value gets stuck at () and at ().

Steps

  1. Get the cycle length from the ladder (first time ).
  2. Divide by and take the remainder .
  3. The answer is (for a bare it is , with the sign of the cycle).
Example 6 · Basic
If , find .
Solution, step by step
  1. 1The cycle is powers long: and then .
  2. 2, so .
  3. 3, so the answer is .
Answer -1
The powers (a multiple of ) make no difference.
Example 7 · Standard
If , find .
Solution, step by step
  1. 1, , . So and the cycle is long.
  2. 2, so .
  3. 3, so the answer is .
Answer -1
For a cycle of look at : remainder gives , otherwise .
Example 8 · Standard
If , find and .
Solution, step by step
  1. 1The cycle is long: .
  2. 2, so .
  3. 3, so .
Answer -2 ; -1
means : at half a cycle the sign flips.
Example 9 · Advanced
If , find .
Solution, step by step
  1. 1. So , i.e. .
  2. 2In the same way and .
  3. 3All three pairs are zero, so the total is .
Answer 0
Powers apart make pairs, because .
Example 10 · Advanced
If , find .
Solution, step by step
  1. 1Squaring road: .
  2. 2, .
  3. 3The value sticks at : , and likewise .
Answer 2
Cycle road: , so and the answer is .

Practice

BasicTry it yourself first
If , then equals:
BasicTry it yourself first
If , then equals:
StandardTry it yourself first
If , then equals:
StandardTry it yourself first
If , then equals:
StandardTry it yourself first
If , then equals:
StandardTry it yourself first
If , then equals:
AdvancedTry it yourself first
If , then equals:
AdvancedTry it yourself first
If , then equals:
AdvancedTry it yourself first
If , then equals:

Expressions with x² + x + 1 = 0

or

When the equation is given and a polynomial value is asked.

The idea

This is the same special value, with the equation given in place of : and . So the same cycle: gives and gives . Bring every power down to , or (with its sign), then put (or ): the terms cancel and a number remains.

∑ Formula
What the two equations give
the cycle relation
three consecutive powers add to zero
Spot itSpot it: big powers like in the polynomial and the given equation . Handy: and (when ) collapse many products in one line.

Steps

  1. Write (multiply by ).
  2. Bring every power down to .
  3. Replace using the equation and cancel the terms.
Example 11 · Basic
If , find .
Solution, step by step
  1. 1Multiply by : , so .
  2. 2 and .
  3. 3Sum: , which is exactly the given equation.
Answer 0
Three consecutive powers adding to zero is the most frequent outcome of this method.
Example 12 · Standard
If , find .
Solution, step by step
  1. 1From the equation .
  2. 2So the numerator is .
  3. 3The value is .
Answer -1
We did not even need here, only .
Example 13 · Standard
If , find .
Solution, step by step
  1. 1Multiply by : , so .
  2. 2 and .
  3. 3Sum: .
Answer 3
If the power has the sign .
Example 14 · Advanced
If , find .
Solution, step by step
  1. 1The terms run from to , in all. Split the first into groups of three: groups.
  2. 2Each group is , because .
  3. 3The last term left is . Total .
Answer 1
The counting: divide the number of terms by and look at the remainder; the leftover terms make the answer.
Example 15 · Advanced
If , find .
Solution, step by step
  1. 1Expand: .
  2. 2 and (because ).
  3. 3Sum: .
Answer 3
Keeping as a ready-made pair is quickest.

Practice

BasicTry it yourself first
If , then equals:
BasicTry it yourself first
If , then equals:
StandardTry it yourself first
If , then equals:
StandardTry it yourself first
If , then equals:
StandardTry it yourself first
If , then equals:
StandardTry it yourself first
If , then equals:
AdvancedTry it yourself first
If , then equals:
AdvancedTry it yourself first
If , then equals:
AdvancedTry it yourself first
If , then equals:
2

Limits

· minimum values

How small can be and what happens at .

Both methods come from one fact: for real , never goes between and .

The limit of x + 1/x and what = 2 means

At we get , and which values are impossible.

The idea

From we get . For , dividing by gives , and for the direction reverses: . So for real the value of never lies between and . Equality happens only when , i.e. (or for ). Hence and . Every power is then a plain number and the question opens in one line. In the picture the two branches of stay outside the band .

◭ Diagram
xy−4−224−6−4−2246y = 1: no meetingy = 3: two points(1, 2)(−1, −2)
: the branches lie only in and . The line meets the curve twice (two values of , reciprocals of each other); never meets it (no real ). (The pale pink band is the forbidden middle zone.)
∑ Formula
The limit rules
a real number,
absolute value (sign removed)

Similarly gives , i.e. , and gives . Trap: in a question with (like ) there is no real , yet the algebra formulas still work; exam questions use exactly this (previous method).

Spot itSpot it: or is given, or the question asks “which value is possible”. First write and then solve by putting in numbers.

Steps

  1. Multiply by to make a perfect square: .
  2. Get .
  3. Put the number into every power; the sign of depends on being even or odd.
Example 16 · Basic
If , find .
Solution, step by step
  1. 1Multiply by : , i.e. , so .
  2. 2Every power of is : .
Answer 0
In such questions the powers are only there to scare you; at everything flattens.
Example 17 · Standard
If , find .
Solution, step by step
  1. 1, i.e. , so .
  2. 2 (odd power), (even power), .
  3. 3Value .
Answer -5
An odd power flips the sign, an even power does not.
Example 18 · Standard
If and , find and .
Solution, step by step
  1. 1, i.e. , so and ; as , .
  2. 2 and .
Answer 2 ; 2
Without we could also have and the first answer could be .
Example 19 · Advanced
Which of can be the value of for a real ?
Solution, step by step
  1. 1 gives ; a real root needs , i.e. .
  2. 2 have absolute value below , so they are impossible; is fine.
Answer −2.2
Check: at , is real.

Practice

BasicTry it yourself first
If , then equals:
BasicTry it yourself first
If , then equals:
StandardTry it yourself first
If , then equals:
StandardTry it yourself first
For real which of these is a possible value of ?
StandardTry it yourself first
If , then equals:
AdvancedTry it yourself first
If , then equals:
AdvancedTry it yourself first
If , then equals:
AdvancedTry it yourself first
For real which of these is a possible value of ?

Minimum and maximum values

The smallest value of expressions like for .

The idea

We saw for . The same with coefficients: expand and you get . The minimum occurs when the two terms are equal: , i.e. . In the picture the curve comes down to its lowest point and rises again. The maximum (for , or for a subtracted term) is the mirror image.

◭ Diagram
xyx = 2min = 8y = 2x + 8/x
(): the lowest point is at with value .
∑ Formula
The minimum-value formula (equality at )
positive coefficients
the minimum value
the at which it occurs

Other forms: , and , , . All have their minimum at (where the terms are equal). For , (a maximum).

Spot itSpot it: “minimum for ” and an expression with and terms. Trap: if the product of the two terms depends on () the formula does not apply; the product must be constant. And for the sign flips.

Steps

  1. Write the expression as plus a constant (dividing by if needed).
  2. Check that the product of the two terms is constant.
  3. Minimum + constant, at .
Example 20 · Basic
For find the minimum value of and the where it occurs.
Solution, step by step
  1. 1, , . Minimum .
  2. 2Equality when , i.e. , .
Answer 6 ; x = 3
Check: at , ✓; at , and at , , both larger.
Example 21 · Standard
For find the minimum value of .
Solution, step by step
  1. 1, , , and the product is constant (the cancels).
  2. 2Minimum , at .
Answer 12
Check: at , ✓.
Example 22 · Standard
For find the minimum value of .
Solution, step by step
  1. 1Expand the numerator: . Divide by : .
  2. 2, equality at .
  3. 3Minimum .
Answer 25
Note: , the geometric mean of the two constants.
Example 23 · Advanced
Find the maximum of for and the maximum of for .
Solution, step by step
  1. 1First: , so . The maximum is (at ).
  2. 2Second: , let (). .
  3. 3The maximum is (at ).
Answer -2 ; -8
For negative the minimum turns into a maximum in the mirror.

Practice

BasicTry it yourself first
For the minimum value of is:
BasicTry it yourself first
For the minimum value of is:
StandardTry it yourself first
For the minimum value of is:
StandardTry it yourself first
For the minimum value of is:
StandardTry it yourself first
For , at which is smallest?
StandardTry it yourself first
For the minimum value of is:
AdvancedTry it yourself first
For the minimum value of is:
AdvancedTry it yourself first
For the maximum value of is:
AdvancedTry it yourself first
For the maximum value of is:
AdvancedTry it yourself first
For , at which is smallest?
3

Two and three variables

· cyclic three variables

The same pair when two or three letters replace .

Calling by turns a two-variable question into the old ladder; with three variables the cyclic move is different.

Questions with a/b + b/a

Put

When or is given and is asked.

The idea

Call by the name ; then . So is exactly the pair , and the whole ladder of the chapter runs here. Dividing the given by gives straight away. The squares of the sum and difference become multiples of : and , whose quotient gives .

∑ Formula
What gives
two non-zero numbers
the given constant
∑ Formula
The sum-product and ratio forms
sum and product
the terms of the ratio
Spot itSpot it: a relation between and is given, or , is asked. Divide by at once, then the old ladder. Trap: comes through a square root; read the sign condition ().

Steps

  1. Divide the given condition by .
  2. Read as .
  3. Apply the ladder (square, cube) or a square root.
Example 24 · Basic
If , find and .
Solution, step by step
  1. 1Divide by : , i.e. .
  2. 2With : ; square: .
Answer 7 ; 47
is the same thing.
Example 25 · Standard
If , find .
Solution, step by step
  1. 1 and .
  2. 2Sum: .
Answer 29/10
The formula is the same.
Example 26 · Standard
If and , find .
Solution, step by step
  1. 1.
  2. 2.
  3. 3Value .
Answer 53/14
Here , : ✓.
Example 27 · Advanced
If and , find .
Solution, step by step
  1. 1 and .
  2. 2Divide: .
  3. 3 ⟹ positive: .
Answer √6/2
(rationalising the denominator).

Practice

BasicTry it yourself first
If , then equals:
BasicTry it yourself first
If , then equals:
StandardTry it yourself first
If , then equals:
StandardTry it yourself first
If and , then equals:
StandardTry it yourself first
If , then equals:
StandardTry it yourself first
If and , then equals:
AdvancedTry it yourself first
If , then equals:
AdvancedTry it yourself first
If and , then equals:
AdvancedTry it yourself first
If , then equals:
AdvancedTry it yourself first
If and , then equals:

Three variables: cyclic pairs

and the fractions

Cyclic questions such as , , .

The idea

Now instead of three variables are tied in a cycle: with , with and with . The ladder does not run here, but the same style of move does: write everything in one variable (first result) or multiply and combine the three equations cleverly to get . Two famous results: (1) if and then and . (2) if with distinct, then and . A third, from the same family: (3) if then .

◭ Diagram
+1/y = 1+1/z = 1+1/x = 1xyzxyz = −1
Read each arrow as: the letter at the tail . The three arrows form a cycle, which is why the third equation comes out true by itself and .
∑ Formula
The cyclic-pair rule
three distinct non-zero numbers
the shared value
∑ Formula
The product- fractions
three numbers with product
Spot itSpot it: three letters tied in a cycle by reciprocals, or three variables with . Move: use in place of a “” so all denominators match; in cyclic equations multiply by (or ) and use the third equation.

Steps

  1. Clear the fractions ( and so on).
  2. Multiply one equation by the third letter and combine with another.
  3. By the cycle the result is the same for every letter; subtract to get and .
Example 28 · Basic
If and , find and .
Solution, step by step
  1. 1From we get , so .
  2. 2From we get .
  3. 3A number check: take , then , . Then and .
  4. 4In general: and .
Answer 1 ; -1
Whatever is (except and ), the result is the same.
Example 29 · Standard
If are distinct and , find and (with ).
Solution, step by step
  1. 1Clear fractions: , , .
  2. 2Multiply the first by : , so . Likewise .
  3. 3Subtracting: ; since , , and gives .
  4. 4Then , i.e. .
Answer 1 ; -1
This is the earlier () result; with we would get .
Example 30 · Standard
If , find .
Solution, step by step
  1. 1Aim: make all three denominators alike. Multiply top and bottom of the second by : ().
  2. 2Multiply top and bottom of the third by : .
  3. 3Sum .
Answer 1
Check with numbers: at , , , ✓.

Practice

BasicTry it yourself first
If and , then equals:
BasicTry it yourself first
If and , then equals:
StandardTry it yourself first
If are distinct and , then equals:
StandardTry it yourself first
If are distinct and , then equals:
StandardTry it yourself first
If , then equals:
StandardTry it yourself first
If , then equals:
AdvancedTry it yourself first
If and , then equals:
AdvancedTry it yourself first
If are distinct and , then equals:
AdvancedTry it yourself first
If with , then equals:
AdvancedTry it yourself first
If and , then equals:
4

Summary, mixed practice, revision

All methods in one place

One table of all methods, exam-style mixed questions and revision cards.

Here is the essence of this chapter and exam-style mixed questions: first spot the method, then solve.

Summary of all methods

Which method when

One page to pick the method as soon as you read a question.

MethodUse whenKey formula / move
Special valuesfirst : ; :
Huge powerlike ; cycles
a polynomial value,
Limit, or which value is possible;
Minimum value, at
, , and ; ;
Three variablescyclic , or , ; fractions add to

Here: , is the cycle length, the remainder of , positive coefficients and (second last row) the sum and product. First ask: is the value between and (a cycle), exactly (a limit), or are there several letters?

Two trapsTwo traps: (1) at , itself is and the ladder is not needed; (2) in a cycle a remainder means (that is ).

Mixed practice — set 1

Basic to standard

All kinds mixed together; spot the method first, then solve.

These questions are not in method order, just like the exam.

BasicTry it yourself first
If , then equals:
BasicTry it yourself first
If , then equals:
BasicTry it yourself first
If , then equals:
BasicTry it yourself first
If , then equals:
BasicTry it yourself first
If , then equals:
BasicTry it yourself first
For the minimum value of is:
BasicTry it yourself first
If , then equals:
BasicTry it yourself first
If and , then equals:
StandardTry it yourself first
If , then equals:
StandardTry it yourself first
If , then equals:
StandardTry it yourself first
If , then equals:
StandardTry it yourself first
For the minimum value of is:
StandardTry it yourself first
If , then equals:
StandardTry it yourself first
For real which of these is a possible value of ?
StandardTry it yourself first
If , then equals:
StandardTry it yourself first
If and , then equals:

Mixed practice — set 2

Standard to advanced

Mixed questions from the hard end of the exam.

AdvancedTry it yourself first
If , then equals:
AdvancedTry it yourself first
If , then equals:
AdvancedTry it yourself first
If , then equals:
AdvancedTry it yourself first
If , then equals:
AdvancedTry it yourself first
If , then equals:
AdvancedTry it yourself first
For the minimum value of is:
AdvancedTry it yourself first
For the maximum value of is:
AdvancedTry it yourself first
If , then equals:
AdvancedTry it yourself first
If and , then equals:
AdvancedTry it yourself first
If and , then equals:
AdvancedTry it yourself first
If , then equals:
AdvancedTry it yourself first
If , then equals:
AdvancedTry it yourself first
If , then equals:
AdvancedTry it yourself first
If , then equals:
AdvancedTry it yourself first
For , at which is smallest?
AdvancedTry it yourself first
If , then equals:
StandardTry it yourself first
If , then equals:
StandardTry it yourself first
If , then equals:
StandardTry it yourself first
For the minimum value of is:
AdvancedTry it yourself first
For real which of these is a possible value of ?

Revision: cards and traps

Flip and recall

Read the front, think, then flip.